Last season, Indianapolis Colts quarterback Andrew Luck had arguably the best year of his NFL career. He threw for 4,593 yards, 39 touchdowns, 67.3 completion percentage, and set career highs in completions (430) and attempts (639). The team went 10-6 and lost in the Divisional Round to the Kansas City Chiefs. It was a comeback season for the former number one overall pick who missed all of 2017 with a shoulder injury.
The shoulder injury was a curious one as it was an injury and surgery that was supposed to only sideline the signal-caller through the offseason, Luck wasn’t even ready to throw a real football in training camp. In the end, he sat the entire season to make sure that he would be perfectly healthy in the future.
Well, we’re in the future and Luck is not healthy. The Colts had spent money and draft capital to try and fortify their roster so that their season wouldn’t live or die on the play of Luck. Pundits were highlighting Indianapolis as a team capable of making a run to Miami for Super Bowl LIV in February 2020.
All the progress and good feelings came to a screeching halt when it was first announced that Luck was dealing with another injury. However, it wasn’t an upper-body injury but instead discomfort in his calf that sidelined him. In March, an MRI revealed that he was dealing with a calf strain in his right leg. During organized team activities (OTAs) and training camp in May and June, the Colts opted to hold out Luck for some practices. By July, head coach Frank Reich was referencing the calf strain and resulting Achilles tear of NBA superstar, Kevin Durant when discussing the precautions the team was taking with the face of their franchise.
Then on Monday, Colts owner Jim Irsay provided us with an update that the team believed that it was a small bone—the os trigonum—that was responsible for the persistent pain that the quarterback was dealing with.
Yet, one day later, general manager Chris Ballard refuted that report (it turns out only 5-10 percent of the population even has an os trigonum) and said that it has become more of an ankle injury. “From the start we’ve been dealing with a calf injury,” Ballard said, via ESPN’s Mike Wells article. “In March through camp, dealing with a calf and then little area below his calf, which Andrew kind of referred to as a lower leg where he was dealing with some pain, almost in the ankle area. The injury wasn’t getting better and hadn’t been practicing, so in the course of dealing with the calf injury, it appears that now we have an ankle issue.”
The NFL season gets underway in less than a month and the Colts aren’t ready to comment on what Luck’s status will be to begin the year. Compare that to 2017, when Irsay was on record saying he didn’t believe the quarterback would miss any time and it’s easy to make an assumption that the current injury situation is worse than the shoulder injury that kept him off the field for an entire season.
When he’s healthy, Luck is one of the best quarterbacks in the NFL. However, in the last four seasons, including 2019, he’s only been 100 percent healthy for one of them. If he is able to return to the field this year then all eyes will be on how he looks. If not, he will likely get brandished with the tag of being injury prone.
Over the course of five months, this injury has not only worsened but moved to a completely different part of the body. It is surely time for this franchise to panic.